Contractor Red Flags

Red Flags to Watch for When Hiring a Painter

A painting quote itemized line by line shows what the price includes. It doesn’t show whether the painter carries insurance or has past customers who would hire them again, something homeowners absolutely must find out both before signing anything.

The sections below explain six red flags to watch for, what each one puts at risk and how a homeowner can check for it.

They also explain the Ontario rules that let a homeowner cancel a contract after signing it, and how to judge a painter who shows more than one.

Nothing in Writing

Ontario requires a written contract for any home renovation job over $50, which covers almost every painting job. A verbal price with nothing in writing is a red flag on its own, since the painter is skipping a step the law requires.

The contract has to cover the following:

  • It gives the painter’s business name, address, and contact information.
  • It describes the work accurately, with an itemized list of the materials used and the services provided.
  • It sets out any warranty on the materials and on the labour.
  • It states the total cost with taxes shown, plus a payment schedule that includes the deposit amount.
  • It gives a work schedule with start and completion dates.
  • It names any subcontractors and says who pays them.
  • It says who prepares the work area and who cleans up afterward.

A homeowner whose contract leaves out any of these can cancel it within one year. If the painter doesn’t start within 30 days of the start date in the contract, the homeowner can also cancel at any time before the work begins.

Beyond the legal minimum, a detailed contract names the product line and sheen for each surface, gives the number of coats on each, and itemizes the prep instead of saying “prep included.”

Under the Consumer Protection Act, a painter can’t charge more than 10 percent above a written estimate unless the homeowner agrees to a new price and signs a change to the contract.

A price quoted only out loud is much harder to hold a painter to, since nothing records the figure.

Sales Pressure

Pressure to sign on the day of the visit is a red flag, whatever reason the painter gives for it. The reason might be a crew working nearby, paint left over from another job, or a price that holds only until the visit ends.

Signing on the spot leaves no time for a second quote, an insurance check, reference calls or a search of Ontario’s Consumer Beware List.

Cold weather ends the exterior painting season, so a fall deadline can be genuine, but it doesn’t require a signature that day.

A homeowner who signed under pressure at home can still cancel the contract for any reason within 10 days of receiving a written copy. The painter then has 15 days from the cancellation notice to refund everything paid, deposit included.

If the homeowner asked the painter to start during those 10 days, the painter can keep reasonable payment for work and materials that can’t be returned.

Ontario advises sending the cancellation by email or registered mail and keeping a copy, since both record the date the notice was sent.

If the painter claimed work was needed when it wasn’t or made any other false statement to close the sale, the homeowner has a full year to cancel, wherever the contract was signed.

Cash Only

A cash discount is a red flag, because the painter offering it usually skips the invoice and the HST.

A business has to register for HST and charge it once its revenue passes $30,000 a year, so a painter who leaves it off the bill is either a very small operation or not reporting the job.

Without an invoice, a homeowner has no record of the job if the paint fails or the work is left unfinished, and loses the usual ways of getting a problem fixed or money back:

  • A warranty claim depends on a written record of what the painter promised.
  • A homeowner who cancels under the Consumer Protection Act and doesn’t get the refund on time can ask the credit card issuer to reverse the charge. A cash payment leaves nothing to reverse.
  • Ontario’s Small Claims Court hears claims up to $50,000, and the paperwork each side brings usually decides who wins.

A cheque made out to the business or a credit card payment creates a record of what was paid and when.

Unverified Insurance Liability Coverage

A painter who can’t show proof of liability insurance is a red flag, since nobody needs a licence to paint houses in Ontario and no provincial rule requires painters to carry coverage.

A painter without insurance has to pay personally for damage to a floor or a neighbour’s car. A small painting business may not be able to cover a large repair.

Before hiring, a homeowner can confirm a painter’s insurance coverage by checking four things:

  • The certificate of insurance came directly from the painter’s insurance company or agent, not as a copy from the painter.
  • The start and expiry dates on the certificate cover the whole project.
  • The per-occurrence limit, which is the most the policy pays toward a single incident, is high enough to cover serious damage to the house.
  • The insurer named on the certificate, reached on a number the homeowner looked up separately, confirms the policy is still active.

WSIB

WSIB pays benefits to workers hurt on the job, and Ontario requires coverage across the construction industry. Home renovation has one exception, for a painter who works alone with no employees and is hired and paid directly by the homeowner.

A solo painter with no WSIB account isn’t a red flag on that basis alone. A painter who brings a crew of employees without WSIB coverage is a red flag, because the painter has to cover employees whatever the exemption says.

Ontario advises homeowners to check a contractor’s coverage with WSIB. A painter with a crew can supply a WSIB clearance certificate showing the account is in good standing.

What the Check Protects

Under Ontario’s Occupiers’ Liability Act, a homeowner who hired a painter reasonably and took steps to confirm the painter was competent generally isn’t liable for the painter’s mistakes. Checking insurance, references and certification is one way to take those steps.

The homeowner still has to keep the property itself reasonably safe for anyone working on it.

Disproportionate Deposit

Ontario recommends keeping deposits to no more than 10 percent of the project cost and never paying the full amount before the work is finished.

Painters who buy materials for a specific project sometimes ask for more. On a larger job, a fair payment schedule ties the rest to progress payments as the painting gets done.

A request for most of the price before work starts is a red flag, because the painter is asking the homeowner to finance the job. A homeowner who has already paid that much has nothing left to hold back if the work stalls.

No References

Ontario advises homeowners to get at least three references from people who dealt with the painter directly. A painter with no references to offer raises a red flag, since it means the painter either started the business recently or would rather the homeowner didn’t phone past customers.

A customer whose job was finished six months or a year ago can say how the paint held up and how the painter handled any problems. A reference can answer questions like these:

  • Did the crew arrive when scheduled, and on consecutive days?
  • Did the crew clean the site at the end of each day, or only at the end of the job?
  • Did the scope change mid-project, and how did the painter handle the price?
  • Has any surface peeled, cracked, or discoloured since?
  • Would you hire the same painter again?

A homeowner can also search Skilled Trades Ontario’s free public register, which lists everyone holding a Certificate of Qualification, to check a painter who claims the voluntary Painter and Decorator certification.

Ontario’s Consumer Beware List, also free to search, names businesses charged or convicted under provincial consumer protection laws, along with businesses that didn’t respond to the ministry about a consumer complaint. Names stay on that list for roughly two years.

Weighing the Red Flags

A single red flag can have an innocent explanation, such as a new company with few references to offer.

When several red flags appear together, as when a painter asks for most of the price up front in cash with nothing in writing, the painter has been paid before the homeowner can check any of the work.

A refusal to put the job in writing is enough to look elsewhere. Any other red flag on its own calls for more questions, and two or three together are a reason to get another quote before signing anything.

Checking takes little time, since an insurer can usually send a certificate of insurance within a day and three reference calls fit into an afternoon.

Established painters keep insurance certificates and reference contacts on hand, since homeowners ask for them regularly. A painter who stalls when asked for them is likely to handle a missed start date or a peeling wall the same way.

Tresham Painting writes itemized quotes for residential and commercial work in Hamilton, Oakville, Burlington, Fonthill, Niagara-on-the-Lake, St. Catharines, Grimsby, Stoney Creek, Niagara Falls, Welland, and the surrounding areas.

Contact the office for a free, no-obligation estimate.

Other Articles

roller-and-brush-strokes
Roller Marks & Brush Strokes
fixing-wall-issues-before-painting
Fixing Wall Damage First
how-to-get-rid-paint-smell-1590643388
Residential Paint Fumes